How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying is an awesome musical. I first saw it in Chichester several years ago with an awesome cast and when I heard it was being revived on Broadway I was actually quite excited – even though I knew I wouldn’t get to see it. Then I heard Daniel Radcliffe was going to be the main character…. Not only do I find it difficult to think of him as an adult and not a 10 year oldf boy wizard but there’s something about him that I don’t like. Watching the latest couple of Harry Potter films he was clearly acted off the screen by everyone and everything including a CGI creature. He’s also a bit too excited about, well, everything and comes across as a smug person trying to be humble, so I was almost kind of glad I wasn’t going to be able to see this production. Then I heard the soundtrack had made it’s way to Spotify where I can listen to it (albeit 5 times and only if I still have time allowed) for free so I can have some form of judgement on Radcliffe’s performance – even though I can’t be sure if hasn’t been tampered with. I’m guessing it hasn’t as I’m only on the first big number and already Radcliffe seems to be struggling with his singing (I dread to think what he’s like when he has to dance around too).
Anyway, the music for the show is brilliant, so I’m going to carry on listening. Don’t want to get myself into a track by track review but will come back when something good or bad happens…
- Coffee Break is just as good as I remember it being when I saw this show years ago! (Maybe it’s because there’s no Radcliffe?)
- Oh, some talking, Radcliffe’s accent is…. interesting.
- Advert time for a Blackberry Play Book – this is exciting me more than the music…. not a good sign :S
- The support cast are either fantasitc or just sound better due to Radcliffe
- 20 seconds into track 18…. Oh. My. Word. It’s a soundtrack recorded in a recording studio over time – how does Radcliffe sound so crap?
- Oh Ghost the Musical is oh Spotify now too – though I did buy the album last week on itunes (but it’s now on Amazon to download for a bit cheaper!)
- I am going to have to give up.
Let me be clear – I love the music, I love the show and I think most of the cast are fantastic – but, call me narrow minded – I just can’t get over Daniel Radcliffe. I saw Joe Macfadden in his role and he was brilliant. Robert Morse in the film is fantastic. Radcliffe…. is making me cringe. I don’t want to feel like this when listening to music.
Well… I went to YouTube to try see a clip of the show and watched this – the performance from the Tony awards:
And my opinion, though not changed, has softened. Softened to a more ‘Gawd-bless-‘im-and-his-little-cotton-socks’ attitude, but still softened. He is doing a much better job than I could do so if any Radcliffe fan girls see this I have admitted he is better than me OK? BUT he still comes across as unnatural, a bit too excitable and slightly ‘high’ (if you get what I mean). Also, anyone else notice how out of breath he gets? I know it’s a high energy number, but there’s a lot of them in this show. I dread to think what he’s like by the end of a full show!
And for a comparrison, here’s Robert Morse in the film of the musical (it’s brilliant, if you can see it do so!) It’s not as big as the above video but it’s still brilliant.